Orton Insurance

We recommend Orton insurance. Gary was actually recommended to us by a good friend. And we think he is a great agent to work with. He is easy to reach, quick to follow up, and very reliable. He is also very personable and professional. He helped us find a plan that was great for our needs and made things run smoothly. We are glad we found him when we did!

Orton Insurance is a valued member of the Rexburg Area Chamber of Commerce, providing trusted insurance solutions and guidance to families and businesses in our community. Their dedication to personalized service and protecting what matters most makes them a reliable and respected local partner. We’re proud to have Orton Insurance as part of our Chamber family!

I highly recommend Orton Insurance. Gary is exceptionally kind, helpful, and knowledgeable. I faced a last minute situation where I needed insurance quickly, and even though it was the end of the workday, and the start of the weekend, he immediately jumped into action. He assisted me with all the necessary paperwork, made phone calls, and worked tirelessly until everything was completed. Thanks to him, we secured the needed insurance. He also made follow up calls to provide updates on the approval status and sent additional insurance details. Gary is always available to address any insurance questions even after the process is complete. He truly goes above and beyond. You won't regret choosing Orton Insurance.

Everyone at Orton Insurance has been so helpful to me and my family ever since they started helping us four years ago. I've turned to them many times for assistance with different issues and they've always helped me work things out to make sure my family has the coverage we need. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for insurance.

I contacted Gary to see if he could help me navigate switching from overpriced (employer) health insurance to finding something more affordable through Your Health Idaho. He called me within the hour of my initial email and spent over 45 minutes just answering my many, many questions. He was so incredibly helpful and thorough! We made a follow up appointment to have him help me through the application process and to finalize an insurance plan for me. He is SO patient! He helped me research and compare so many different plans and made sure my application looked correct before submitting it. I can't recommend him enough. I'm so grateful for his never-ending patience, knowledge, and kindness.