Community Insurance

New Holland, PA · Insurance agency

Rating
4.4/5
★★★★☆ 4.4
Reviews
14
Rank in New Holland
#1
of 5 insurance agents
City Percentile
50%
rating percentile
Address
Community Insurance, 684 W Main St #1, New Holland, PA 17557
Phone
(717) 354-4551
Website
www.communitysure.com

Community Insurance is an insurance agent located in New Holland, PA. It is one of 5 insurance agents listed in New Holland. Its 4.4-star rating matches the New Holland city average of 4.4 stars. Based on combined rating and review volume, it currently ranks first among insurance agents in New Holland. There is 1 photo associated with this location.

About Community Insurance

Community Insurance is a locally owned, independent insurance agency dedicated to serving individuals, families, nonprofits, and businesses throughout Lancaster County and beyond. Our team is rooted in the communities we serve and committed to... More

Customer Reviews

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Dwayne White · Feb 2026

I have been a customer of this agency since 2000. My wife even longer as I joined her policy once we were married. We have a situation that I believe could have been handled better. I understand what was being told to me. I understand the why. However, I have found that regardless of procedures and other factors, big companies can still find ways to help their loyal customers when they want to. When someone tells you there is "nothing we can do" or "our hands are tied", it typically means they do not want to do anything. Perhaps it's too hard, too much work, or just not worth their time. I still believe that something can be done if they "really wanted to" do so. So consider where you decide to pledge your insurance business and customer loyalty for the long haul and that you wi

★★★★★ 5.0 Teresa Crego · Feb 2026

I recently reached out to Jon Hundley at Community Insurance to get a fresh look at my homeowners and auto policies. I’d been with my previous agency for years, but the constant homeowners rate hikes—and the lack of real answers—made it clear it was time to explore other options. From the start, Jon took the time to actually get to know me. He wasn’t just trying to throw the cheapest rate at me and move on. He walked me through several options, explained the pros and cons in plain language, and helped me land on what made the most sense for my family long‑term. He even connected with my 23‑year‑old son, reviewed his auto policy, and gave him recommendations that ended up improving his coverage and lowering his cost. What really stood out was the follow‑through. Jon checked in to make su

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Kenny Brown · Mar 2022

If I could put zero stars I would... I had Paul Black as an insurance agent. Started with him in early 2021 and dropped him in the fall of 2021. There was zero communication between me and him, especially when I needed him or had to make some adjustments to my policy. Never replied to emails, texts, or calls. Worst part about this whole situation was that I filled out all the proper paperwork to have my payments taken out automatically. Well come to find out there was 6 months worth of payments that was never taken out. I was approached about this and was demanded to pay over $1200 on the spot in order to continue the policy. After resolving this issue for what I thought, i decided to just drop the agency. Well I received a call today from a collections company demanding over $600 to be pa

★★★★★ 5.0 Colleen Duty · Aug 2017

I have been working on our personal auto policy as well as getting my aunt established with Community Insurance. Blanche has been wonderful to work with. She is very knowledgeable, helpful, patient and willing to take the time to help you understand the "ins and outs" of insurance. Would recommend them highly.

★★★★★ 5.0 Michael Buterbaugh · Jan 2018

We have auto, HO, commercial, and PCL insurance policies handled here. Never once had to wait for a complete and clear response to to any questions I posed or to changes I needed to make in any policy. Superior service and communication.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot

Services

Insurance agencyAuto insurance agencyDental insurance agencyIncome protection insurance agencyInsurance agentInsurance brokerInsurance companyMotorcycle insurance agencyRenter's insurance agency

Top Insurance Agents in New Holland

NameRatingReviews
Goodville Mutual Casualty Company★★★★☆ 4.020 reviews
Millenium Insurance Group Inc★★★★★ 5.04 reviews
Lancaster Mutual Insurance Company★★★★☆ 3.88 reviews
Nationwide Insurance: Kma Insurance Group LLC★★★★★ 5.02 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.