McMahon Insurance Agency

McMahon Insurance Agency has always made the complicated process of getting insurance easier for me. They answer all my questions and are easy to get a hold of. Recently, Kathleen Ward did an amazing job of finding us a much better car insurance policy that saved us a little over $1000. Definitely recommend!

BEST service, BEST rates/premiums, and BEST everything---for YEARS! And a special Thank You goes to Mark Grampp yet again for his help, efficiency and professionalism EVERY time I contact him. McMahon Agency rocks! Respectfully & cordially always, Kevin Doran of Galloway Twp., NJ; 3/4/2026. :o).

As a realtor in Ocean City, I recommend this agency to all of my clients. I can always count on my representative Kara Reilly to help me and my clients with finding the best policies and premiums. She never minds helping with even the most minor of requests like additional copies of declarations pages for insurance companies, etc. I have been a McMahon "member" for many years, and Kara is one of the reasons why I continue to have the McMahon Agency handle all of my "down the shore" insurance needs.

I had an amazing experience with McMahon Insurance Agency for our condo insurance. The entire team is incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and truly cares about helping their clients. Kara Reilley goes above and beyond—always quick to answer questions, explain coverage clearly, and make sure I’m getting the best possible protection. It’s rare to find an agency that makes you feel this supported and valued. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable, friendly, and top-notch insurance service!

Have used McMahon agency for our Ocean City NJ beach house for over ten years. Our agent, Katie Wolak, is quite exceptional. She’s always available to answer questions or help us navigate through the ever changing complexities of home insurance and flood insurance. As insurance companies are constantly changing rates, and looking for reasons to drop customers, Katie has always been on our side looking for the best possible coverage. Very happy with McMahon, and love working with Katie. She’s the best!!!