Keslar Insurance Agency - Rochester Office

I cannot recommend Ethan Keslar highly enough. From our very first conversation, it was clear that he genuinely cares about his clients. He took the time to thoroughly understand my needs, explain every option in clear and simple terms, and ensure I felt confident in every decision. What truly sets him apart is his responsiveness and professionalism. Whether answering detailed questions, comparing coverage options, or assisting with policy updates, he was always prompt, knowledgeable, and incredibly patient. I never felt rushed or pressured—only supported. His expertise made what can often feel like a complicated and overwhelming process completely seamless. Thanks to his guidance, I now have coverage that gives me real peace of mind. If you're looking for someone trustworthy, attentive, a

After working with the same insurance agency for over 25 years, we were incredibly disappointed when they dropped the ball on our coverage. We spent weeks calling other agencies and either couldn’t get callbacks or couldn’t get the help we needed. Then we found Keslar Insurance — and the difference was immediate. You actually speak to a real person. Skye reached out right away, took the time to understand our business needs, and followed through exactly as promised. Within less than two weeks, to our relief, she secured the full coverage we needed for our business. The responsiveness and professionalism were such a relief after our previous experience. We’re very grateful and highly recommend Skye & Keslar Insurance!

Amy Howard is fantastic to work with. I’m continually impressed by her kindness, thoroughness, and genuine care for her clients’ best interests. She went above and beyond to help me find the right home and auto insurance, and even encouraged me to compare options if there was a chance I could secure comparable coverage at a lower cost. Amy has earned my trust and loyalty, and I will absolutely continue working with her for all of my insurance needs. If you are looking for an agent, look no further than Amy!

Posting a shout-out for my favorite insurance agent, Amy Howard! Amy is one of those rare professionals who makes insurance simple, stress‑free, and genuinely personalized. She takes the time to understand your situation, explains your options clearly, and finds solutions that truly fit, not just whatever’s easiest. Whether it’s reviewing coverage, answering questions, or helping navigate a policy change: Amy is always responsive, thoughtful, and incredibly easy to work with. Personally, she helped me navigate a complicated Auto insurance situation and proactively went out of her way to save me thousands a year! If you’re looking for an insurance partner who is trustworthy, knowledgeable, and fully committed to your peace of mind, I highly recommend connecting with Amy at Keslar Insuranc

Great working with Amy Howard at Keslar! She is super knowledgeable and walked us through multiple options for Homeowner, Umbrella, and Auto Policies. We were able to get better coverage for less money - best of all peace of mind that our coverages are appropriate & our needs well looked after. :)