Colligan and Company Inc - Insurance Agency

We are all blessed with special talents. Driving and the desire to price shop quotes from 1-800 insurance lines are not mine. Back in 2024, after a couple of back-to-back accidents, found myself in a real pinch related to auto insurance. They don't teach you how to navigate these situations in school. Found myself asking many questions and not finding clarity on how to move forward in my situation. Stumbled backwards into local, trustworthy, and independent insurance agent recommendations. Dustin Shirey from Colligan was top of the list. Gave him a call and picked his brain. He did not pressure me into switching to him. Offered "no strings attached" advice that was practical and reassuring. Have purchased insurance through him ever since. Excellent at what he does and a pleasure to work wi

I recently switched to Colligan & Company. The rates were far better than my previous insurance company (saved hundreds). Jeremy has been very helpful and responsive. I am very glad that I made the switch and look forward to working with them for a long time. If you are looking to switch insurance companies I would recommend looking into Colligan & Company.

Was looking for new home and auto insurance and contacted Jeremy at Colligan & Co. Jeremy is very personable and easy to talk with. I recommend him highly. He followed up with a thank you email and the receptionist also called later and thanked me for joining their "family". Customer Service is alive and well at Colligan and Company!

We’ve trusted Colligan & Company with our personal insurance for over 30 years and our business coverage since 2018—their prompt follow-up and the ease of having everything in one place has made them an outstanding partner.

Dustin S. has been so easy to work with. His quick responses to my many questions and multiple changes to vehicles and policy have been met with grace and accuracy. We continue to do our business with his agency and recommend him to others in need. Thanks again for all your help, Dustin.