Carter Insurance Agency - Middlebury

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Carter Insurance Agency in Middlebury provides outstanding service from start to finish. The team is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely cares about finding the best coverage for your needs—not just selling a policy. They take the time to explain options clearly and make the entire process easy and stress-free. Whether you need auto, home, or business insurance, you can trust them to deliver reliable advice and great value. Highly recommended!

Emma is great. Replaced my auto, homeowners and umbrella and saved me dough. When problems arose with the carrier, she was there. High marks!

Emma is the best! She responds immediately when emailed. We own a business and often need to provide COI for our customers. I have never waited over an hour for that task to be completed. She is amazing and a wealth of Insurance knowledge! We couldn't be happier!

With the high increase of insurance, I decided my current insurance agency wasn't trying to get the best rates for me. After many years of the same agency, I decided to give Carters Insurance a try to see what rates they could get for me. Jessica Laughlin worked with me and it was a great experience. I was able to decrease the amount I pay for my home and auto, she also was able to get me way more coverage. I am beyond grateful for an amazing experience with Jessica. Thank you so much for all of your efforts to get me the best rate possible.

I used to change insurance companies based on cost bi-annually, and have always been apprehensive about using a local agent. I mean, they must be making their money off of me, right? The team at Carter insured me, my three other drivers, my home, and my business for far less than what I was paying previously and below my google searches. Not to mention their team! Super friendly, knowledgeable and GREAT to work with. Chat with the bots with the big carriers if you'd like. I'll take the better rates and outstanding customer service myself. Fyi- I don't get anything from posting this review, my experience with Carter makes me want to share. When is the last time you felt that way about any company, never mind insurance. Yours truly, Avid non-reviewer of anything! Aka Jake (and "no" I'm not