Shoemaker's Insurance and Financial Services LLC

Went too 2 other insurance companies in Newville a they just took my info and told me I’d get a call. shoemaker was only one that actually sat down with me a got me an insurance plan right away at a good cost! Thank u!!

We went here to transfer tags and insurance and notary services. We are always met with a friendly face here. You get the personal touch here. They do their best to be sure you are happy. I recommend Shoemaker's Insurance.

would not recomend this office ! having issues with my life inc. been calling them for several months several times a day left several messages even to the owner and they have never called me back! the only reason I gave them a 1 star because there is nothing lower !

I did my research and contacted Shoemaker’s after reading positive Google reviews. I have not had a positive experience w/Shoemaker’s. It’s been months w/out a quote for farm/auto insurance. Last communication was on Sept 9th via telephone asking for additional info from me. Provided initial copies of present policy, etc in July. I sent an email last Monday saying I was hoping to receive some numbers by now…. Today a week later I sent another email expressing my disappointment and that I was no longer interested in receiving a quote. Within 25 minutes I received a reply email with a “sorry Jodee” explaining that’s it been “intense” there lately and the numbers he had were not good. I asked that my file/case be closed and Nathan informed that it was. Very disappointing experience w/Nathan

Sara Rhine in commercial insurance and Owner Nathan Shoemaker's team for personal and healthcare insurance redefine excellence. Sara's expertise and dedication ensure tailored solutions for businesses, while Nathan's team goes above and beyond in personalized care. Sara Rhine is a true standout in commercial insurance, providing unmatched expertise and dedication. She crafts solutions that precisely meet the unique needs of each business, instilling confidence in her clients. Nathan Shoemaker and his team excel in personal and healthcare insurance, offering a level of care that's truly exceptional. They go beyond policies, understanding and addressing the individual health goals and financial situations of their clients. If you're looking for insurance professionals who combine industry