Shelter Insurance - Cargile Insurance Agency Inc.

Deborah McFarlin is hands down the best insurance agent I have ever worked with. She is incredibly responsive and somehow always comes through exactly when I need her most. I have had situations where I needed quotes or policies turned around very quickly, and she has had everything ready the same day without hesitation. There have even been a couple of moments where I was pulled over and realized I didn’t have my insurance card on me. I called Deborah right then, and she immediately texted it to me. Ticket avoided. Stress gone. That alone deserves a five star review. Beyond her speed and professionalism, Deborah genuinely cares. She is friendly, puts her customers first, and always makes me feel like more than just a policy number. She feels like a friend at this point, and that kind of

Rhonda Roberts has been my agent for many years, and has always handled everything with great care. She has helped me with many different types of coverage, and has been a trusted advisor for what I need and do not need. I can reach out to her with questions and count on her to respond quickly and with the perfect answer. I will always keep my insurance with Rhonda!

I worked with Maria at Shelter to get us set up for insurance for our home and vehicles. Her service goes above and beyond and I was able to get switched over seamlessly as well as save a pretty penny compared to what I was paying for when I was previously insured with Country Financial. I'll continue to trust Maria with our policies moving forward.

Such a wonderful group of folks at the Cargile Agency! They've helped us save money and get great coverage, and held our hand when we've had claims to work through. Keep up the good work Cargile team! Shout out to Mrs. Deborah for always being the real MVP!!

This is hands down the best insurance company I've worked with. Excellent customer service, quick responses, and reasonable prices. I would highly recommend the Cargile Insurance Agency Inc.