Proper Insurance Services, LLC

We had an outstanding experience working with Matthew Stewart at Proper Insurance. From start to finish, he was transparent, communicative, and incredibly helpful. He took the time to explain every detail of our policy, answered all of our questions clearly, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. It’s rare to find someone so professional and responsive -- Matthew went above and beyond to make sure we were fully covered and confident in our decisions. I would absolutely recommend him and Proper Insurance to anyone looking for trusted, knowledgeable service.

Mathew Steward at Proper Insurance was incredibly helpful in managing our claim. Everything was handled with professionalism and, most importantly, efficiency. His follow‑up was excellent, and he was truly a pleasure to work with. Highly recommended.

I want to celebrate Matthew Stewart of Proper Insurance-- he was remarkably patient and helpful with managing my claim and ensuring that I got the support I needed. It made all the difference to have his careful attention and assistance with the many annoying setbacks and frustrations of dealing with contractors and other dynamics in fixing my house. I'm really thankful and definitely suggest Proper to others!

I'd recommend Proper if you have vacation rental, great partner! It's hard to find good insurance company, they normally send you around when you need them the most, not with Proper! My contact was Elizabeth Young from start to finish, she was outstanding, responsive, professional and helpful, explain things clearly. Thank you!

Start to finish, Payton Voss has been outstanding. There was never a lull in waiting for questions to be answered, and all of my vacation rental needs were addressed and met with such expertise and professionalism. I cannot say enough about Payton, and my experience with Proper, overall. So glad to have received the recommendation from a neighbor who also found it increasingly more difficult (to impossible) to insure vacation rentals in California. Payton (and Proper) for the win!