Consolidated Insurance Services Inc

Palmyra, PA · Insurance agency

Rating
4.3/5
★★★★☆ 4.3
Reviews
17
Rank in Palmyra
#2
of 3 insurance agents
City Percentile
50%
rating percentile
Address
Consolidated Insurance Services Inc, 127 E Main St, Palmyra, PA 17078
Phone
(717) 838-1391
Website
www.cispalmyra.com

Consolidated Insurance Services Inc is an insurance agent located in Palmyra, PA. It is one of 3 insurance agents listed in Palmyra. Its 4.3-star rating is slightly below the Palmyra city average of 4.7 stars. It ranks #2 among Palmyra insurance agents by combined rating and review volume.

About Consolidated Insurance Services Inc

Local, Independent Insurance Agency serving Palmyra and surrounding communities for over 70 years.

Customer Reviews

★★☆☆☆ 2.0 Matt Boltz · Nov 2025

I was looking for a quote for homeowners insurance, and when I called back the next day, after I gave my information, she said they had someone walk by my house and I would probably need the porch fixed, handrails added, etc. I attempted to clarify that she was referring to the incorrect house and that I had handrails, but she continuously interrupted me. She never tried to obtain the quote; I just got the feeling that she would rather not help me. I ended the phone call and went with a different Insurance broker.

★★★★★ 5.0 Joshua Tillett · May 2025

Been with Consolidated insurance for over 15 years. Justin, Maegan, and the staff at consolidated have been great to work with. They are honest, trustworthy, and reliable people to deal with. Very grateful for the work they do!

★★★★★ 5.0 Courtney Cerjanic · May 2023

I highly recommend Consolidated Insurance Services. Matt continuously goes above and beyond in helping me when I have questions, need to add policies, or simply need updated insurance documentation. I use Consolidated Insurance Services for both personal & my business as their rates have always been the best I've found. Any time I have any questions, issues, or need general help Matt is quick to respond and gets me what I need. Overall I have had an incredible experience and would recommend them to anyone needing insurance.

★★★★★ 5.0 Jared Jamison · Apr 2020

Every time I sit back and think about the perfect day, I dream about smashing my hand in a door, eating lima beans, and shopping for insurance. All kidding aside, both Justin and Consolidated Insurance have been professional, fast, responsive, and their insurance - with no compromise in coverage - has been less expensive for my business and personal needs. And guess what? I didn't have to repeat "auto policy" 5 times while getting interrupted by a computer saying, "I'm sorry. I didn't get that," and I didn't have to "press 1 followed by the pound sign." I was able to talk directly to a person who lives and works in the same area as I do. So, if you are in the market for insurance, at the very least, make sure this group is at the top of your list.

★★★★★ 5.0 Shelby Koch · Jul 2024

I've worked with this location for many years. No matter when I call, to add, drop, change or just have general questions everyone is professional and helpful. They're consistently timely in their responses and have been such a pleasure to work with!

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot

Services

Insurance agencyAuto insurance agencyHome insurance agency

Top Insurance Agents in Palmyra

NameRatingReviews
Kelly Parks - State Farm Insurance Agent★★★★★ 5.020 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.